Introduction
A basic how-to needed to be written on backyard wild edibles, --insects and other oft’
overlooked critters, in particular. Too
many books calling themselves books on “wild edibles” sadly neglect those
little edible invertebrates. I wondered,
“Why don’t I write something?” Ideas bombarded me
from every direction and the starting point wasn’t making itself known. I wondered, “If someone is interested in eating wild
stuff, where would they start?”
First
is curiosity, which leads to deciding whether or not to actually eat wild weeds
and bugs on purpose. If so, the would-be
locavore (cool term for eating locally, but I didn’t make it up) acquires the wild
stuff, prepares it, eats it and ultimately should want to share their findings. With that order in mind, this writing is built.
You’re
actually looking at this, so you’ve got some curiosity. You know it’s about eating bugs and other
wild stuff and haven’t thrown it down. You
got past the title. That “eww-factor” is
probably the most difficult hurdle in wild edibles. Some of you might, however, be reading this
because you’re being forced, maybe to write a report or something, so I’ll
give a little background on why we shouldn’t be afraid of eating some of the
stuff others might call “weird.” It’s
been done for centuries and by many cultures.
It’s nutritionally sound. Some
say it’ll even help save the planet.
To
eat wild stuff, you first need to actually get hold of some, and finding it
isn’t always easy until you know what you’re doing. Not all wild stuff is safe to eat. Usually, it takes some effort to eat your
first wild stuff, although the occasional bug may fly right into your
mouth. Safety includes knowing what to
eat and how to prepare it.
After
you’ve fixed wild edibles a few times, you’re bound to stumble across some you
actually like. What fun is enjoying
something without sharing it? That’s a
big part of this text, so you’ll also find some ways to share your new culinary
knowledge.
Getting Started
Some
folks ask, “How did you ever get started eating that stuff in the first
place?” The scene goes all wavy as we
slip back to the mid 1960s in suburban Minneapolis. Grandma told me, as she pointed out some prostrate
knotweed (Polygonum aviculare, I think), “Butterflies eat that.” I figured since butterflies fly, and that’s
what they eat, I might as well give it a try.
I ate a fair amount of the stuff, and found that my leaps from the top
of my slide were getting farther and farther.
I must have been learning to fly.
Something came up and I seemed to have forgotten about my aeronautical
pursuits.
Later, and still in my
single-digit years, I thought I’d try something else. I made sure nobody was watching. With a magnifying glass, I heated the worm to
a crisp. Still, no witnesses. The earthworm turned black, so I guessed it
was cooked through. I glanced around
again and popped it in my mouth and quickly started chewing. I hadn’t yet heard about purging worms a few
days to rid their systems of dirt. It
was gritty as I chewed, but I must admit, it didn’t taste good either. I didn’t go for seconds, and earthworm is
still not a main item on my menu.
Several
years later, in my early teens, I discovered chocolate covered bugs at my local
grocery store. They never became more
than a novelty, probably because of the expense. The flavors weren’t distinct enough and I
could get pretty much the same texture from a Nestle’s Crunch or Hershey’s
Crackle. Besides, anything can taste
good if it’s smothered in chocolate.
I’d
also read about eating dandelion greens, wild fruits and nuts, and that there’s
lots more stuff out there we can eat,
and people actually do eat. I started looking at quite a few books on
wild edible plants and even tried a few, other than that early knotweed. Every now and then, I’d stumble across a
reference to someone eating bugs, but, my interest in eating them took a break
for over thirty years. Then Sonja came
into my life.
First Experiences With Entomophagy
Several
years back, Sonja came into our library with some questions. Her quiet
school-teacher manner seemed in stark contrast to her request for information
on fried grasshoppers and sources of supply.
As I considered her request, I
remembered buying chocolate-covered ants, bees, grasshoppers and caterpillars
back in the early '70s when our Golden Valley, MN, Byerly's carried them.
Byerly's doesn't carry them anymore. I checked a while back on a visit to my
parents. The teacher's request didn't shock me like it did some. It turned out
the teacher was going to serve fried grasshoppers to some of the more daring
teachers for a back-to-school function or something like that --quite possibly
in remembrance of the big Warrensburg grasshopper feast of 1875.
Several
librarians and I jumped on the project.
The school teacher ended up buying two packages of hoppers and only used about half of one. I don’t remember if we or she found her source of supply. She nonetheless remembered our eagerness to find information and offered the leftovers to us at the library. Only one of us (guess who) was adventurous enough to take her up on the offer. She didn't want any payment –only to get them off her hands.
The research introduced me to websites and several books, which seemed to taunt me with, "I dare you to pursue this!" And here I am, unashamed to admit that I eat bugs from time to time, and on purpose.
Those commercially procured grasshoppers of the teacher's, though much larger than the ones in my yard, didn't impress me with their flavor or texture. Maybe they were fried in lard or shortening. Maybe they'd have been better with seasoning. I finished the open pack, and about half the other pack. The remainder ended up getting thrown out because I had no idea how long they stayed fresh. Over the months it took to reach that point, I'd looked at several of the books and websites we found while doing the original research.
Entomophagy is not just about fried grasshoppers, exotic monster-grubs from Papua New Guinea and chocolate-covered stuff. One source, and credit information escapes me, explained that the author had been researching entomophagy. On a trout-fishing trip, he ran into a huge hatch of mayflies and wondered what the trout found so good about them. He tried one, then another, and ended up laying his fishing equipment down and eating his fill of mayflies. Shortly after reading that, I was mowing on my tractor and my own yard happened to be quite thick with mayflies. I tried them too, and for quite some time, mayflies weren't safe around me.
During my early entomophagous experimentation, I discovered I like raw mayflies and young grasshoppers. Older hoppers were a bit too strongly flavored for me. In a recent book I read, the author pointed out something that should have been obvious to me. Eating uncooked insects poses the same threats of disease and parasites as eating under and uncooked meats of other types. I pondered that thought and my raw insect-eating days were all but over.
Not long after giving up raw "bugs" (entomologically incorrect, but etymologically correct, as The Eat-A-Bug Cookbook's David George Gordon points out), I ran across a bunch of tomato worms on my in-laws' tomato plants. The Eat-A-Bug Cookbook has a recipe for Fried Green Tomato Hornworms, so I collected all I could find from those plants. I only got about a dozen. They ranged in size from about an inch and a half to almost four inches long. My wife humored me and didn't protest, even though she knew what I was up to. A month or so earlier, she only smiled (and maybe rolled her eyes) as she peeked into a frying pan to catch me dry-roasting some grasshoppers, which ultimately found their way powdered into a hoppin'-good hot sauce. The day after the tomato worm find, I caught several grasshoppers, a cicada, and a couple field crickets. I finally had enough critters to perform another culinary experiment.
After killing the snack by freezing, I thawed them out while tossing them in soy sauce. I cut up some white onion and sweet-pickled ripe red jalapenos (from my garden) and heated up a bit of olive oil. In went the critters and they sizzled up a storm as the water steamed out. A couple of the tomato worms burst, so I adjusted the heat and kept on frying and stirring until the grasshoppers turned deep red-brown and the worms turned almost yellow. Then I stirred in the vegetables and continued until they were nicely browned.
I must admit I was quite pleasantly impressed at the outcome! Aside from the oniony, sweet and hot, salty flavors from the other ingredients, which was really quite good, the individual critters had flavors and textures all their own. In many books, you'll read of "nutty" and "smoky" flavors. The tomato worms didn't have that. They were quite similar to thin tubes of thick pea soup. The mere bulk of "stuff" in a tomato worm may take some getting used to, but they're really not all that bad. The cicada tasted and felt like a nut stew inside a big sunflower seed shell. I couldn't get the shell chewed, so, like a piece of gum that'd lost its flavor, I spit the shell out. The grasshoppers were, like most people say, sort of smoky and nutty in flavor. I particularly liked the light and crispy texture. Finally, the crickets were most impressive, like crispy, smoked oyster. They were great!
When I get a good batch of kimchi, pickles, pepper brownies or jalapeno cookies, I like to share them, so I had to bring a big sample of the bugs to friends. I'd already picked out my intended victim, due to her reaction to the hoppin' good hot sauce a couple weeks earlier. When I asked if anyone was interested in my latest experiment, I said, "It's not the hoppin' good hot sauce that had the powdered grasshoppers in it." She said she didn't like the idea of hot stuff, but the grasshopper part sounded interesting. Be careful what you say. You never know when it may come back to you.
Within minutes, I brought in the previous night's leftover stir-fry, having to fight myself not to eat it all up, so I could share it. My first victim looked nervous as she said, "I thought you'd maybe bring it in in a couple days, not just a minute or two." She didn't want an audience for her first entomophagous attempt, so I suggested we slip off to the break room. There was someone else in the break room, so we had an audience, but still not a big one. The audience was also one who tries most of my other stuff –but not this.
After looking into the stir-fry, the victim said, "Ew, I don't want to try a tomato worm!" I poked the chopsticks in and pulled out a grasshopper. She asked, "What's THAT?" The legs and wings were gone, and it looked similar to a long, shiny raisin. I told her it's a grasshopper and her face went into a skeptical twist as she slowly extended her hand. I think she might have even given a little shiver as the morsel hit her hand. She put it in her mouth and slowly began to chew. Her eyes got big and she started to smile and said, "Oh my gosh! That was good!" She eagerly accepted another, bigger hopper. The response from later adventurous eaters has all been positive.
On my way to make a book-delivery to one of our library branches, I stopped at my favorite convenience store. Some of the guys who work there eagerly try my culinary experiments. One likes them well enough I often bring him his own bottle of the experiments. As I walked in, I asked if anyone felt adventurous. The new guy said, "If it's anything like that kimchi I tried, I'm game!" I said, "This stuff isn't hot at all," and for a second or two, silence fell. The old-timer with my culinary goodies broke the silence with a hesitating, "What's in it?" "Well, aside from soy sauce, onions, and a bit of those pickled jalapenos, there's critters."
The new guy said, "Whoa, not me! I'm skittish enough around bugs." I said, "It's your chance to take revenge." He didn't go for it, but Old-Timer said, "You know, I'd heard of eating insects and have been meaning to try it some time." I said I had grasshoppers and tomato hornworms. Old-Timer laughed and said no tomato worm for him, but he'll try a grasshopper.
Old-Timer started chewing and he put up his hand, saying, "Mmmm, Hmmm", between chews. "It tastes like… like… I can't quite put my finger on it… It's not bad…" Then I told the guys about the cicada and cricket. New Guy said he'd have tried a cricket "because they're little." Neither of them was disappointed that I'd already eaten the cicada.
Since then, I've learned to catch grasshoppers by flashlight on a cool night. It’s similar to picking berries. New Guy also asked me to bring some grasshoppers again because he was ready to try them.
The other day, I thought I’d call a bluff. Two ladies who work at one of the libraries on my delivery route said they were interested in trying my entocuisine. I brought in part of batch number two. This time there were no tomato worms or cicadas, but it included peach-pit meats, which are very almond-like. One of the ladies declined after seeing the bowl, but the other didn't back down or even hesitate.
I ate one hopper while telling about the adapted recipe, as a patron who looked into the bowl staggered off with her hands fluttering like a butterfly, shuddering and repeating, "Ew, ew, ew." Daring Librarian had a cricket and the patron "Ew"ed again. Then Daring Librarian had a grasshopper, saying, "These are really good, though I'm most partial to crickets." Another "Ewww!" was heard in the distance. We didn't eat it all, so I had a fair bulk of leftovers for dinner.
While camping the following weekend, I was reading my Bible by lantern-light and a big grasshopper hit me in the chest. I picked it off and gently tossed it to the weeds. Another bounced off my head and landed in the Book. I only smiled as it hopped off into the dark. Before this, I'd probably have absent-mindedly squished 'em. The next day, again, while reading, a big ant crawled along the edge of the table and I reached out, tapped it with a finger and popped it in my mouth. I realized what I'd done, and glanced around to see if anyone saw me. I think I got away with it. Ants are tart!
So now, as I drive around on my library delivery routes and scan the countryside, it now hits home harder how abundantly God has provided for us. Am I ready to throw caution to the wind and be a hunter-gatherer? No way! I like my metal pans, freezers, refrigerators, running water, stove and oven, my car, and other benefits of civilization. Those, too, are gifts of God.
The school teacher ended up buying two packages of hoppers and only used about half of one. I don’t remember if we or she found her source of supply. She nonetheless remembered our eagerness to find information and offered the leftovers to us at the library. Only one of us (guess who) was adventurous enough to take her up on the offer. She didn't want any payment –only to get them off her hands.
The research introduced me to websites and several books, which seemed to taunt me with, "I dare you to pursue this!" And here I am, unashamed to admit that I eat bugs from time to time, and on purpose.
Those commercially procured grasshoppers of the teacher's, though much larger than the ones in my yard, didn't impress me with their flavor or texture. Maybe they were fried in lard or shortening. Maybe they'd have been better with seasoning. I finished the open pack, and about half the other pack. The remainder ended up getting thrown out because I had no idea how long they stayed fresh. Over the months it took to reach that point, I'd looked at several of the books and websites we found while doing the original research.
Entomophagy is not just about fried grasshoppers, exotic monster-grubs from Papua New Guinea and chocolate-covered stuff. One source, and credit information escapes me, explained that the author had been researching entomophagy. On a trout-fishing trip, he ran into a huge hatch of mayflies and wondered what the trout found so good about them. He tried one, then another, and ended up laying his fishing equipment down and eating his fill of mayflies. Shortly after reading that, I was mowing on my tractor and my own yard happened to be quite thick with mayflies. I tried them too, and for quite some time, mayflies weren't safe around me.
During my early entomophagous experimentation, I discovered I like raw mayflies and young grasshoppers. Older hoppers were a bit too strongly flavored for me. In a recent book I read, the author pointed out something that should have been obvious to me. Eating uncooked insects poses the same threats of disease and parasites as eating under and uncooked meats of other types. I pondered that thought and my raw insect-eating days were all but over.
Not long after giving up raw "bugs" (entomologically incorrect, but etymologically correct, as The Eat-A-Bug Cookbook's David George Gordon points out), I ran across a bunch of tomato worms on my in-laws' tomato plants. The Eat-A-Bug Cookbook has a recipe for Fried Green Tomato Hornworms, so I collected all I could find from those plants. I only got about a dozen. They ranged in size from about an inch and a half to almost four inches long. My wife humored me and didn't protest, even though she knew what I was up to. A month or so earlier, she only smiled (and maybe rolled her eyes) as she peeked into a frying pan to catch me dry-roasting some grasshoppers, which ultimately found their way powdered into a hoppin'-good hot sauce. The day after the tomato worm find, I caught several grasshoppers, a cicada, and a couple field crickets. I finally had enough critters to perform another culinary experiment.
After killing the snack by freezing, I thawed them out while tossing them in soy sauce. I cut up some white onion and sweet-pickled ripe red jalapenos (from my garden) and heated up a bit of olive oil. In went the critters and they sizzled up a storm as the water steamed out. A couple of the tomato worms burst, so I adjusted the heat and kept on frying and stirring until the grasshoppers turned deep red-brown and the worms turned almost yellow. Then I stirred in the vegetables and continued until they were nicely browned.
I must admit I was quite pleasantly impressed at the outcome! Aside from the oniony, sweet and hot, salty flavors from the other ingredients, which was really quite good, the individual critters had flavors and textures all their own. In many books, you'll read of "nutty" and "smoky" flavors. The tomato worms didn't have that. They were quite similar to thin tubes of thick pea soup. The mere bulk of "stuff" in a tomato worm may take some getting used to, but they're really not all that bad. The cicada tasted and felt like a nut stew inside a big sunflower seed shell. I couldn't get the shell chewed, so, like a piece of gum that'd lost its flavor, I spit the shell out. The grasshoppers were, like most people say, sort of smoky and nutty in flavor. I particularly liked the light and crispy texture. Finally, the crickets were most impressive, like crispy, smoked oyster. They were great!
When I get a good batch of kimchi, pickles, pepper brownies or jalapeno cookies, I like to share them, so I had to bring a big sample of the bugs to friends. I'd already picked out my intended victim, due to her reaction to the hoppin' good hot sauce a couple weeks earlier. When I asked if anyone was interested in my latest experiment, I said, "It's not the hoppin' good hot sauce that had the powdered grasshoppers in it." She said she didn't like the idea of hot stuff, but the grasshopper part sounded interesting. Be careful what you say. You never know when it may come back to you.
Within minutes, I brought in the previous night's leftover stir-fry, having to fight myself not to eat it all up, so I could share it. My first victim looked nervous as she said, "I thought you'd maybe bring it in in a couple days, not just a minute or two." She didn't want an audience for her first entomophagous attempt, so I suggested we slip off to the break room. There was someone else in the break room, so we had an audience, but still not a big one. The audience was also one who tries most of my other stuff –but not this.
After looking into the stir-fry, the victim said, "Ew, I don't want to try a tomato worm!" I poked the chopsticks in and pulled out a grasshopper. She asked, "What's THAT?" The legs and wings were gone, and it looked similar to a long, shiny raisin. I told her it's a grasshopper and her face went into a skeptical twist as she slowly extended her hand. I think she might have even given a little shiver as the morsel hit her hand. She put it in her mouth and slowly began to chew. Her eyes got big and she started to smile and said, "Oh my gosh! That was good!" She eagerly accepted another, bigger hopper. The response from later adventurous eaters has all been positive.
On my way to make a book-delivery to one of our library branches, I stopped at my favorite convenience store. Some of the guys who work there eagerly try my culinary experiments. One likes them well enough I often bring him his own bottle of the experiments. As I walked in, I asked if anyone felt adventurous. The new guy said, "If it's anything like that kimchi I tried, I'm game!" I said, "This stuff isn't hot at all," and for a second or two, silence fell. The old-timer with my culinary goodies broke the silence with a hesitating, "What's in it?" "Well, aside from soy sauce, onions, and a bit of those pickled jalapenos, there's critters."
The new guy said, "Whoa, not me! I'm skittish enough around bugs." I said, "It's your chance to take revenge." He didn't go for it, but Old-Timer said, "You know, I'd heard of eating insects and have been meaning to try it some time." I said I had grasshoppers and tomato hornworms. Old-Timer laughed and said no tomato worm for him, but he'll try a grasshopper.
Old-Timer started chewing and he put up his hand, saying, "Mmmm, Hmmm", between chews. "It tastes like… like… I can't quite put my finger on it… It's not bad…" Then I told the guys about the cicada and cricket. New Guy said he'd have tried a cricket "because they're little." Neither of them was disappointed that I'd already eaten the cicada.
Since then, I've learned to catch grasshoppers by flashlight on a cool night. It’s similar to picking berries. New Guy also asked me to bring some grasshoppers again because he was ready to try them.
The other day, I thought I’d call a bluff. Two ladies who work at one of the libraries on my delivery route said they were interested in trying my entocuisine. I brought in part of batch number two. This time there were no tomato worms or cicadas, but it included peach-pit meats, which are very almond-like. One of the ladies declined after seeing the bowl, but the other didn't back down or even hesitate.
I ate one hopper while telling about the adapted recipe, as a patron who looked into the bowl staggered off with her hands fluttering like a butterfly, shuddering and repeating, "Ew, ew, ew." Daring Librarian had a cricket and the patron "Ew"ed again. Then Daring Librarian had a grasshopper, saying, "These are really good, though I'm most partial to crickets." Another "Ewww!" was heard in the distance. We didn't eat it all, so I had a fair bulk of leftovers for dinner.
While camping the following weekend, I was reading my Bible by lantern-light and a big grasshopper hit me in the chest. I picked it off and gently tossed it to the weeds. Another bounced off my head and landed in the Book. I only smiled as it hopped off into the dark. Before this, I'd probably have absent-mindedly squished 'em. The next day, again, while reading, a big ant crawled along the edge of the table and I reached out, tapped it with a finger and popped it in my mouth. I realized what I'd done, and glanced around to see if anyone saw me. I think I got away with it. Ants are tart!
So now, as I drive around on my library delivery routes and scan the countryside, it now hits home harder how abundantly God has provided for us. Am I ready to throw caution to the wind and be a hunter-gatherer? No way! I like my metal pans, freezers, refrigerators, running water, stove and oven, my car, and other benefits of civilization. Those, too, are gifts of God.
Early Experiences with Wild Edible Plants
Besides
the earlier-mentioned prostrate knotweed, which, I don’t recommend since I’d
not found any documentation on its ediblity, and it’s not all that good, some
species of knotweed are edible. I’d tried lots of other plants.
My
early foraging didn’t strike me as being collecting wild edibles, because most
of it was with my grandmother: and besides, “everybody did it”. We went berry picking quite a bit. We’d usually pick choke cherries, red
raspberries or blackberries. It was
rare, but I did stumble across some wild strawberries, blueberries, and a
special treat, while hunting with my dad, wintergreen berries. I believe my grandmother mentioned in
passing, that lamb’s quarter was edible, but I don’t remember having eaten it
as a kid.
On
my own, I sampled what I called onion grass, which I later learned was wild
onion greens. I heard Indians ate
acorns, so I tried some, too. I wasn’t
impressed. I found them way too
astringent --of course, now I know you’re supposed to boil them several times
to leach the acid out of them.
I
didn’t really get serious about learning until I reached my 20s.
Beware of the "Facts"
For entomophagy to reach the widest audience, I honestly
believe it needs to stay agenda-free. You’ve
probably heard how man is causing our climate to change for the worse, and that
raising beef and other mainstream meats is adding copious amounts of greenhouse
gasses to the air, and it’s eating up all the rain forests. You’ve probably heard about how we’re going
to run out of mainstream meat in just a few years. There’s also lots of data to show otherwise,
but, the media loves a crisis. After
all, normalcy doesn’t sell. It’s not
emotional or shocking. My promotion of
entomophagy is mainly for fun. And why
shouldn’t we look into all available foods?
Some entomophagy and vegetarianism promoters will throw out
convincing-sounding "facts" and data. Insects are almost as
high in protein, ounce for ounce, as other meats, with lots less fat while
others claim insects to be high in fats and therefore a high energy food.
You can get everything you need from only plants. A plants-only diet is lacking in some
necessary nutrients. Bugs and wild
plants are jam packed with other nutrients you could never get in mainstream
meats or non-organic farming. Entomophagy could go a long way to solve
world hunger while greening up the environment and saving all kinds of money on
resource costs compared to beef. Data can be manipulated or twisted or
presented in ways to support just about any claim or point of view. Don't blindly accept data and
"facts" without thinking for yourself.
I won't argue the claim that we in the West, eat too much
beef or that there are other sources of protein besides mainstream meats.
Much of the data, or at least the conclusions based on that data, has too many
holes in it. You can probably tell by now, I’m not an activist promoter
of entomophagy. I feel like I’m in the
minority in that respect. Don't get into
entomophagy or go on a crusade for it based on shock-data. Do it because
it's fun and could someday draw enough attention to provide a reasonable
alternative to beef or pork. If you have
enough fun with it, others will catch on, and maybe someday entomophagy will
replace the other so-called environmentally unfriendly and less healthy
mainstream meats. It just makes sense to exploit all our food
sources. Get buggy!
But Why Eat Bugs?
A
good question to explore, other than “Why eat bugs?” is “Why NOT eat
bugs?” It’s gross. Bugs are dirty. What would the neighbors think? Look at a pig or a cow by the barn. Look at some fresh-from-the-nest eggs. Look, even at a tomato or head of lettuce as
it sits in the garden. How about caviar,
escargot, shrimp, crab…? All those can
be dirty. We wash them. We clean them. We make them edible: just like we can do with
bugs. It’s gross, and what would others
think, are just cultural excuses created out of ignorance. The reasons not to eat bugs are not really reasonable, when you consider why we
should eat bugs.
Most
of the world already eats bugs, but most of the Euro-American world
doesn’t. Many experts speculate as to
why this is, and I do, too.
It’s been thought the reason
people in industrialized societies learned to despise bugs came way earlier
than industrialization. It began when agricultural crops started replacing
hunting and gathering. Bugs began to be seen as pests, and therefore, bad. I
think bug-hate is much closer to us than that in time.
For many in European and North American culture, an urban life is all they know. Limited exposure causes most to lack knowledge of insects. Many industrialized or urbanized folks see insects as filthy, like flies on poop or roaches around garbage. Many bugs spread disease. Ticks, mosquitoes, chiggers, horse flies, deer flies and gnats all bite. Wasps and bees sting. Maggots infest spoiled foods. Therefore, insects are bad and nasty. The conclusion is based on experience, but at the same time, ignorance of the vast numbers of non-nasties and the good aspects of many of the nasties.
Rural people are usually exposed to a much wider array of bugs than are urban people. It might be likely that rural people could be easier to reach with entomophagy than the urbanized, since bugs are often more a part of rural lives. When bugs are a natural part of life, they’re easier to deal with, and maybe to accept as a possible food source. Living with something makes it more acceptable. I’ve not seen lice crawling on my wife or kids, and find the thought a bit grotesque, but if I was used to it, I don’t know. I might be able to pick and eat like I see ‘em do on documentaries.
For many in European and North American culture, an urban life is all they know. Limited exposure causes most to lack knowledge of insects. Many industrialized or urbanized folks see insects as filthy, like flies on poop or roaches around garbage. Many bugs spread disease. Ticks, mosquitoes, chiggers, horse flies, deer flies and gnats all bite. Wasps and bees sting. Maggots infest spoiled foods. Therefore, insects are bad and nasty. The conclusion is based on experience, but at the same time, ignorance of the vast numbers of non-nasties and the good aspects of many of the nasties.
Rural people are usually exposed to a much wider array of bugs than are urban people. It might be likely that rural people could be easier to reach with entomophagy than the urbanized, since bugs are often more a part of rural lives. When bugs are a natural part of life, they’re easier to deal with, and maybe to accept as a possible food source. Living with something makes it more acceptable. I’ve not seen lice crawling on my wife or kids, and find the thought a bit grotesque, but if I was used to it, I don’t know. I might be able to pick and eat like I see ‘em do on documentaries.
Maybe we could reach urban folks
by appealing to being stylish.
Entomophagy is getting more and more popular, and several celebrities
speak about it openly. Even some upscale
restaurants feature insects on their menus.
So be cool; eat bugs!
I
am curious about different foods and about my surroundings. I also know many species of insects are
edible and many are actually good! Those
are the main reasons I eat bugs. They’re
also the reasons I eat purslane, rose hips, spiderwort, day lilies, and drink
sumac and goldenrod teas and roasted chicory root coffee. Those are also the reasons I try unfamiliar
items at a church pot-luck, and enjoy ethnic restaurant buffets. Curiosity has caused me to eat turtle, snake,
raccoon, ‘possum and even lutefisk: more than once! After Mommy or Daddy quits providing
everything we eat, isn’t curiosity pretty much the reason we try anything new?
Curiosity
isn’t the only reason to eat bugs. Bugs can
be surprisingly nutritious. They’ve got
lots of protein. Unlike most mainstream
meats, bugs can also be high in calcium.
Some people say if we eat more bugs, we will reduce pollutants we put
into our environment, and make our food supplies go farther. Some researchers even think undigested fats
in our intestines adhere to insect chitin for a ride out of our systems. Vincent M. Holt, in 1885, wrote a
most-excellent book on why we should eat bugs, without resorting to lots of
technical and scientific data to publish with it. The book is simply titled Why Not Eat Insects? I like Holt’s approach. If you want a bunch of data, there are lots
of books out there, and hopefully, this won’t be the only book on entomophagy
you read. Curiosity, nutrition and
environment are only three reasons to eat bugs.
It
is fun to eat bugs. Entomophagy is also quite
a conversational tool, since it’s hard not to have an opinion on the
topic. Sharing your culinary creations
is enjoyable, providing you don’t easily take offense at rejection. Watching someone go from shuddering at the
thought, to trying some, while their faces melt into smiles and hearing, “Wow!
That’s good!” is quite rewarding.
The
more popular entomophagy becomes, the less expensive it will be. So let’s eat bugs and fuss at our local
grocery stores until everyone carries them and even competes for price.
What Do They Taste Like?
As
mentioned earlier, Mayflies are a pretty good choice for a first insect to eat. I won't recommend eating them raw as I did back
then. Their flavor and texture were
excellent, but, cooked is safer. Anyway,
I popped my first Mayfly in my mouth and chewed quickly, to get it over
with. It was very tender, with no hard
legs or wings or anything else to gross out a typical Western palate. The only crunchiness was akin to the softer
parts of lettuce leaves, or maybe like poppy seeds. Flavor-wise, it was rather like a cool fresh
juicy leafy vegetable. It wasn't my last
one, by any means. The Mayfly experience
made me bolder.
Later
in the summer we have lots of grasshoppers at our place. Eating them raw, I discovered the younger,
wingless grasshoppers were more tender and milder than the bigger adults. That's not the case with all species. Cone-headed, long-horned grasshoppers, katydids
and green tree crickets have recently become favorites of mine. While collecting, those will be separated
from the others as more of a delicacy.
While walking outside with my son, years ago, I pointed to some lamb's
quarter (an edible "weed") and said, "This stuff's edible and
good," while popping the top of the plant in my mouth. He gasped and asked, almost stuttering, 'D…
Dad… did you s… see that…" And I
answered, "Sure, those grasshoppers are edible, too." I was fairly pleased that the little green
grasshopper stayed on that plant-tip as I picked it and popped it in my
mouth.
Most
people who won’t try bugs can’t seem to get past their appearance. After appearance, unknowns like texture and
flavor tend to be obstacles. Bugs aren’t
like our more mainstream foods. They
have textures and flavors all their own.
Textures range from undetectable as when they’re ground into powder and
added to flour, to soft and squishy like a boiled tomato worm, to hard and fibrous
like an adult cicada or big grasshopper where you chew until you’re ready to
quit, then spit out the shell. Many people
will say bugs have a smoky or nutty flavor.
To a point, they’re right, but the flavors are really more unique than
that. It can be an acquired taste, but
it doesn’t take long to acquire it, at least for some species.
Some
of the softer-bodied, least-threatening backyard species to eat include:
conehead grasshoppers, katydids, crickets (house, field, leaf and camel),
roaches (social barriers to roaches might make them inedible to the squeamish
–as are meat-fly maggots for me at the time of this writing), mantids (too fascinating
a bug for me to eat), freshly-hatched cicadas, mayflies, dragonflies (like
mantids, I don’t like to hunt these), walking sticks, woodlice, and though not
really “soft” bodied, Japanese beetle bodies are very brittle, making them
quite easy to eat.
Harder
to eat, due to heavier exoskeletons, are most grasshoppers, June bugs, giant
waterbugs and adult cicadas. These can
be like chewing on sunflower seeds in the shell. Chew ‘til you’ve extracted the flavors and
edible parts, then spit out the shell, or prepare them in such a manner they
become brittle and shatter when chewed.
Unique
textures abound. Caterpillars and grubs
can be like sacks of thick soup. They’re
great for fear-factor events. I like to
tell contestants to bite down slowly and feel the skin tighten up and get
almost hard. Faces of on-lookers twist
into all sorts of frightened or grossed-out contortions. Then the contestant almost jumps as the skin
bursts and the juice splashes into their mouths. Usually, they ponder the experience for a few
seconds and finish up with, “That was pretty good!” Consider, also, the textures of spiders,
scorpions, slugs, snails and earthworms.
Earthworms cook up to a texture like soft rubber bands. Textures of even the harder bugs can be
changed with different heats of frying, or with dehydrating. I like dehydrated bugs, as lots of the
fibrous hard-to-chew stuff becomes quite crispy and brittle. Imagine light crepes or crispy rice cereal or
thin hard-candy coatings as textures.
Chew thoroughly, as some of the parts can be difficult to swallow if
they go down wrong.
If
you don’t want to deal with the more-difficult-to-chew parts, remove them
before eating or cooking. Some people
recommend breaking the legs, wings and wing covers off the bugs first. Some take the heads off. I usually don’t bother. What you do is up to you.
The
flavors vary between different bug species.
Some taste quite a bit like their food.
Various caterpillars and grasshoppers taste like leafy greens. Some bugs have sweetish flavors, and many
have faintly smoky or nutty flavors. I
don’t particularly like using that “smoky nutty” description, because it’s used
a lot in other books and writings on insects.
It’s like saying about other meats, “it tastes like chicken.” There’s way more to bug flavors than smoked
nuts.
Little invertebrates (bugs) I’ve
intentionally eaten include 2 kinds of roach, 4 crickets, around a dozen
grasshoppers/katydids, 5 or more scarab/June beetles, over 4 beetle larvae, 5
true bugs, darkling and click beetles, stick bugs, May flies, dragon and May
fly nymphs, tomato worms, green and gray “inch” worms, hackberry butterfly
larvae, bagworms, tent caterpillars, army and cut worms, at least 3 kinds of
cicada, dobson flies and nymphs, mousie grubs (hover fly larva), crane fly
larvae, wood lice, more than 3 kinds of plant hopper, at least 3 kinds of ants,
2 wasp larvae, at least 4 kinds of earthworm, 5 kinds of commercial canned or
frozen insects and more. So I’ve tried well over 70 kinds of bugs; I’ve got
some favorites.
After having tried many different kinds of bugs, my favorites include squash and shield bugs, June beetles, crickets, big grasshopper “drumsticks”, bagworms and Japanese beetles. Squash bugs are naturally sweet with a faint spiciness. June beetles have a smoky flavor and are substantial but still easy enough to chew. Japanese beetles are very brittle and shatter when bitten, making them really easy to eat. Crickets and bagworms are soft to chew. Crickets have a sort of shrimp-like flavor and bagworms are planty-juicy. Grasshopper drumsticks (not dried) are a treat. Bite the tip off the fat end of the leg and use your teeth to squeeze the meat out of the broken end. What you end up with is a B.B to small pea-sized chunk of meat which is very crab-like in both flavor and texture.
Some aquatic bugs taste much like the water from which they’re taken, which can be somewhat stagnant, at times. Grubs can also take on the flavor of the leaf-litter or dirt in which they live. I don’t particularly care for that dirty-water or rotted-leaf flavor. I also include bamboo caterpillars and silkworm pupae as examples that “edible” doesn’t necessarily mean “good”.
After having tried many different kinds of bugs, my favorites include squash and shield bugs, June beetles, crickets, big grasshopper “drumsticks”, bagworms and Japanese beetles. Squash bugs are naturally sweet with a faint spiciness. June beetles have a smoky flavor and are substantial but still easy enough to chew. Japanese beetles are very brittle and shatter when bitten, making them really easy to eat. Crickets and bagworms are soft to chew. Crickets have a sort of shrimp-like flavor and bagworms are planty-juicy. Grasshopper drumsticks (not dried) are a treat. Bite the tip off the fat end of the leg and use your teeth to squeeze the meat out of the broken end. What you end up with is a B.B to small pea-sized chunk of meat which is very crab-like in both flavor and texture.
Some aquatic bugs taste much like the water from which they’re taken, which can be somewhat stagnant, at times. Grubs can also take on the flavor of the leaf-litter or dirt in which they live. I don’t particularly care for that dirty-water or rotted-leaf flavor. I also include bamboo caterpillars and silkworm pupae as examples that “edible” doesn’t necessarily mean “good”.
To
summarize this section: Bugs taste like bugs.
Bugs feel like bugs in your mouth.
I know those statements wouldn’t convince many people to try bugs. It’s really something that has to be
experienced. After you’ve chewed them up
and swallowed them, you’re likely to say, “Hmm.
That wasn’t too bad.” Or even,
“Wow, that was good!” But like books on
most topics, reading about eating bugs and actually eating them are completely
different, so don’t stop here!
Acquisition
You
want to eat bugs, so now you’ve got to find them. Acquisition narrows down to three ways: buy
them from a commercial supplier; raise your own; catch the locals. Since I’m an outdoorsy type, this book will
concentrate most on the third method.
The
easiest way to get your bugs is to buy them.
Larger ethnic markets sometimes carry commercially canned, frozen or
dried bugs. Other places you can buy
bugs are bait and tackle stores, pet shops, bird-watching suppliers, home and
garden centers and on the Internet. Always
know the ingredients. Some pet food
insects feature ‘reptile attractant’ and I have no idea what that is. If you buy your bugs to eat, you’ll save lots
of work, but miss out on lots of fun. Commercial
insects can also be pricy. The missed
fun is like buying a TV dinner, compared to hunting or fishing, or gardening
for a meal.
Raising
bugs yourself, doesn’t need to be highly expensive or take lots of room. A bug farm doesn’t need to be labor
intensive, either. Crickets, roaches and
mealworms are easily-raised home grown critters.
A
mealworm farm starts easily. Begin with
two shallow plastic containers. With
lids is best, to keep the nerves of skittish family members at ease. Put an inch or so of bedding in the
pans. Bran of some sort is most common
for bedding material. I get mine from a
local feed store. Into the first pan,
put your mealworms, and wait.
Occasionally, give them a small slice of apple, or potato or other moist
fruit or vegetable to provide water.
They don’t need much. Watch the
pan when pupae start to form, because beetles will follow shortly. Start the second pan with beetles. When you’ve got enough beetles in pan number
two, start harvesting pan number one.
After a while, you should have a pan for harvest, and another with the
next batch growing up and getting fat.
That said, I find it easier just to buy dried mealworms from my local
wild bird food supplier.
Crickets
and roaches are almost as easy as mealworms, but require more escape proof
containers. Tightly-sealing aquariums
are good for them. They’re also a little
more dependent on water than mealworms.
Crickets and roaches use moist dirt for bedding, and might even need
places to hide. I’m not sure why they
need hiding places. Maybe they’re more
self-conscious than mealworms, or suffer from insecurity issues.
I get most of my edible bugs by collecting
wild ones which have raised themselves.
Catching your own bugs raises the more safety questions than
commercially acquired bugs. One big
reason more developed countries enjoy better health is we pay much closer
attention to cleanliness. Cleanliness is
very important when it comes to food. If
you're going to eat bugs, which too many people think are filthy in the first
place, you're going to want to pay special attention to making sure you only
eat clean ones. Another very important
question that needs to be answered before eating is whether the species is safe
to eat. Some species, clean or not, can be
very toxic.
The
most important step is to study your food, and know what species have proven to
be safe or unsafe to eat in the past. In
a true survival situation, you might not have the luxury of knowing the various
species. For wild plants, there is a
universal safety test, but I've not found anything like it for bugs. I threw a bit on bugs into the plant
test. After all, one can’t eat plants
without getting a bug from time to time.
The test is as follows:
Universal Edibility Test
1. Test only one part of a potential food plant at a time. Treat different stages of insect development as different critters.
2. Separate the plant into its basic components - leaves, stems, roots, buds, and flowers.
3. Smell the food for strong or acid odors. Remember, smell alone does not indicate something is edible or inedible.
4. Do not eat for 8 hours before starting the test.
5. During the 8 hours you abstain from eating, test for contact poisoning by placing a piece of the food you are testing on the inside of your elbow or wrist. Usually 15 minutes is enough time to allow for a reaction.
6. During the test period, take nothing by mouth except purified water and the plant part you are testing.
7. Select a small portion of a single part and prepare it the way you plan to eat it.
8. Before placing the prepared food in your mouth, touch a small portion (a pinch) to the outer surface of your lip to test for burning or itching.
9. If after 3 minutes there is no reaction on your lip, place the food on your tongue, holding it there for 15 minutes.
10. If there is no reaction, thoroughly chew a pinch and hold it in your mouth for 15 minutes. Do not swallow.
11. If no burning, itching, numbing, stinging, or other irritation occurs during the 15 minutes, swallow the food.
12. Wait 8 hours. If any ill effects occur during this period, induce vomiting and drink a lot of water.
13. If no ill effects occur, eat 0.25 cup of the same plant part prepared the same way. Wait another 8 hours. If no ill effects occur, the food, as prepared, is most-likely safe for eating.
CAUTION
More Safety Points
Avoid
gathering wild edibles close to roads, especially downhill from a road as they
may be contaminated by oil runoff from cars.
Also consider herbicides and pesticides.
Don't collect wild edibles (plants or critters) from water in which you wouldn't willingly go swimming. Boiling the edibles may help to disinfect them.
If you have a very sensitive digestion or problems with allergies, you should avoid using wild edibles as food. They’re not as thoroughly researched as mainstream foods, and some say insects should be avoided if you have seafood (crab/lobster/shrimp) allergies.
Sometimes, but not always, toxins can be boiled away. The arum family (araceae –Jack-in-the-Pulpit and Green Dragon) contains high concentrations of oxalic acid that aren’t always neutralized by boiling.
Avoid unknown plants that have a bean pod or look like a tomato, potato, or morning glory. Many nightshade members are toxic.
Avoid wild edibles and plant parts that smell like almonds or root beer or have a chemical or otherwise disagreeable odor.
Avoid “edibles” that may have developed mold, or dead critters if you don't know the cause of death.
Regarding insects, a first rule, and really not a rule at all, as a short study will reveal, deals with an insect's appearance. "Red, orange or yellow; avoid that fellow. Green black or brown; wolf it down." If an insect is drawing attention to itself, it must be pretty confident that it's safe from predators. If an insect spends its life trying to hide or not be seen, it might be the bug knows it's tasty.
As thorns warn of plant danger, spines, stingers, odor, bites and other obvious defenses warn of potential bug-danger. If your bug is flashy or displays warning signs, you probably shouldn't mess with it.
These are NOT absolute rules, in the same manner "leaflets three, let it be" is not an absolute rule. If we all followed that rule, we wouldn't eat strawberries or raspberries or lots of beans and peas. The above are first-line safety warnings for those who might not know what they're getting into.
For the most part, grasshoppers, katydids, crickets, roaches, dragonflies, mantids, scarab (the June-buggy ones) beetles and white and gold larvae of beetles are pretty safe to eat, even if you don’t know the individual species. Even some of the above can be unsafe if they’re unclean or diseased.
You need to know your bug's history before eating it. As you wouldn't pull a plant out of a bubbling sewage lagoon and pop it into your mouth, you shouldn't pull a bug from a dumpster or off a juicy rotting bit of road kill and expect a tasty, safe snack. You wouldn't eat an apple off the tree in an orchard if you knew it was covered with pesticides. If you thought there might be some poisons on an otherwise edible plant, you would wash it. Likewise, you shouldn't collect bugs in an area where they or their food plants might have been poisoned. Don’t pick Japanese beetles off sprayed rose plants. The bugs you eat should be clean.
You might find your bugs already dead. A friend could give some to you, or you could even find them in a store or market for sale. You really need to know how they died and how long they've been dead, and how they've been stored. The main question here, is, “Do you trust the source?” Since bugs are structurally similar to many shellfish, I like to suspect them to be subject to quick spoilage.
As the plant test stresses, start with tiny quantities of an unknown insect, not a big mouthful. Work up to meal-sized portions very slowly.
When you consider the Universal Edibility Test, note the time it takes to test a potential wild edible. You could be days or weeks before finding something you can safely eat. There’s no substitute for knowing what you’re doing before being put in a survival situation.
On several occasions, I tried bugs for which I’d seen no documentation on edibility. My experience was lots more than simply knowing “people can eat bugs.” I employed the bug safety rhyme. I knew of similar edibles. I knew the bugs’ environment. I wanted to try more critters. I’d since found documentation on some, but my own writing is the only documentation I’d seen for others. Those experimental species for me include: squash and box elder bugs, water boatmen, crane flies, bark boring beetle larvae and hackberry butterfly larvae.
Once you’re certain of what kinds of bugs you can eat, you’ll want to actually collect them. You’re now a predator. You can catch bugs by hand. You can trap them. You can pick them like berries when they’re vulnerable like when cold or on a window screen. Select your quarry and go after it!
Some of my common prey includes: grasshoppers and crickets, ants (all stages), wasp and bee larvae and pupae, June bugs and grubs, Japanese beetles, click beetles and their grubs, diving beetles, bark beetle larvae, darkling beetle larvae and pupae, crane flies and their larvae, mosquitoes, mantids, walking sticks, dragonflies, May flies, wood lice, roaches, cicadas, hackberry butterfly larvae, tomato and tobacco horn worms, cutworms, bagworms, shield bugs, marmorated stink bugs, giant and medium waterbugs, water boatmen, water scorpions and more.
Spot and pounce is a simple way to get bugs. It might be a good source of exercise, too. Just walk around ‘til you spot a grasshopper or cricket or other bug known to be edible, and sneak up on it and grab. Be careful not to smash it. Bugs might be proportionately lots stronger than we are, but we’re way bigger. Some bugs bite or sting, so be prepared for it. Some have prickly parts that might startle you.
A net offers an advanced approach to spot and pounce. I like to make my nets out of curtain sheer material, rather than the flimsy stuff sold as butterfly netting. An old badminton or tennis racket can make a nice and durable frame, but it is a bit on the small side. Tools make our work easier. Traps are other tools which make the work easier.
Almost anyone can turn on a light on a warm Spring or Summer night and pick bugs off a window screen. Some bugs, like Japanese beetles and June beetles can be attracted to traps. Like I said before, you need to be sure of where the bugs came from. Trapping probably shouldn’t be done in an urban setting, as those bugs you bring in, may have been exposed to toxins. If there’s any chance of contamination, bugs from traps using chemical attractants should not be eaten. Grasshoppers can be easily collected on cool late summer or autumn nights. They can also be fairly easily netted on cool mornings.
Carry a collection container so you’re ready when you get opportunities to collect. Eventually you’ll get to the point you won’t startle easily at bugs when most people jump. You’ll grab, instead.
Here’s a little story of one of my early experiences. Warm, humid and dark, with a little
breeze. I'd been looking, for days, for the big cicada hatch (Brood XIX
in 2011) that was supposed to be happening. I'd also been leaving lights
on and checking windows for June bugs and other critters. All total, over
the past couple weeks, I'd only gotten five or six June bugs, and seen only two
empty cicada shells and one adult. Up until this night, it had been too
cool and clear. Critters are not nearly
so apt to swarm around lights during bright moon-lit or cool nights.
Then it happened! We
didn’t get nearly the hatch of our neighbors to the south and east of us. I was quite excited to pick up to 25 emerging
cicadas per tree trunk, while our southeastern neighbors were sweeping them off
their sidewalks to keep from slipping in them.
The warmth even brought out the June beetles in pretty big numbers.
Get outside after dark, with a flashlight. Look
anywhere you can think –tree trunks, undersides of branches and leaves, fences,
flower patches, buildings, and even on the ground. You'll probably
surprise yourself at the stuff you'll find. Collect your bugs alive, and
kill them by freezing. Store them that way until you're ready to cook
them.
I go collecting with a small plastic coffee creamer
bottle. It's got a little shaker lid with a hinged-door on the opening
just the right size for most June bugs, grasshoppers, cicadas and more.
When I'm done collecting, I put the bottle in the freezer, and about 15 minutes
later, the critters are ready to sort into sandwich bags.
I found lots of June bugs on foliage, and not all on my window
screens. They seem to be rather partial to young leaves from sucker
plants that sprout from stumps. Periodical cicadas, when they’ve got a
nice hatch on, can be found on just about anything. Annual cicadas are
bigger than periodicals, hatch a week or so later, but don't hatch in such
bulk. Then there's grasshoppers late in the summer. Almost all
these critters pick quite easily. They're not nearly so skittish at night
–particularly the diurnal insects like grasshoppers. Fall insects, like
grasshoppers, pick best on cool nights when the temperatures have them slowed
down a bit. Crickets are probably easiest to acquire by trapping, or from
a bait shop, and they're mighty tasty! I'm particularly fond of those
brown camel crickets, common in many basements.
I seriously don't believe a few entomophagists can put a
dent in an insect population, unless the insect is rare to begin with. After
about a week of collecting that Spring, I'd gotten about a quarter pound of
June bugs and cicadas in the freezer –more cicadas than June bugs. I've
got a little less than that in mealworms I raised in my basement. Try
raising your own ento-treats, but if you pick wild, be respectful. Never
eradicate a population –unless, of course, you're picking pests from your
garden. And if you pick regularly, you shouldn't need to use pesticides.
Reduced pesticide use will make the green folks happy.
So now you've got all this neat stuff you can eat. Let’s
fix some bugs!
Cooking your Bugs
Pouring
live grasshoppers into your frying pan won’t work. Hopefully none of you are turning here to see
what you might have done wrong, while grasshoppers jump all over your
kitchen. Your bugs should, for most
practical purposes, be dead before cooking.
A very humane way to kill bugs is by freezing. Their systems simply slow down until they
stop. Start cooking with dead bugs. As stated earlier, make sure you know how
your bugs died.
Clean
your bugs by rinsing them well in a colander under a brisk spray of water. Although not a necessary step, pre-boiling
your insects can help keep them from spoiling.
If you boil promptly after killing, you won’t wonder in what state that
package in the freezer might be. You can
always serve as is, or re-cook. Of course,
if you’re ready to cook and serve, the boiling can be omitted after the
kill. The recipes which follow assume
the bugs have been pre-boiled, unless specifically stated otherwise.
Some
experts say rinsing and boiling aren’t necessary and that they take from an
insect’s natural flavors. Lots of those
flavors are said to be in the pheromones on their bodies, which can be rinsed
off. I still like to at least rinse my
wild edibles –plants and bugs.
Boiled Bugs
Boiled
insects will serve well at fear factor events, or for survival purposes. Although some bug species taste OK boiled,
further cooking can enhance flavors and textures immensely!
Place
bugs in a saucepan and cover with water.
Bring to a boil. Cover and simmer
for 5 to 10 minutes. Boil for storage,
after you’ve killed the insects. Boiled
bugs are ready to eat or store. Boiling
is not necessary if you plan otherwise to immediately cook and serve.
Don’t
throw out that broth! You can use it for
fear factor events as “Bug Juice” or use it to make rice or barley. The broth has a subtle pleasant flavor
similar to goldenrod tea. Some of you
are asking, “similar to what!?”
Goldenrod tea is as close a similar flavor as I could come up with. Of course, if you have no clue what goldenrod
tea tastes like, I forgive you. Expand
your horizons.
*****
Only
a few specific recipes are given here.
This assumes, since you’re adventurous enough to eat bugs, you’re likely
adventurous and creative enough to adapt other recipes to insects: specially after
getting some basics. My first
successful, or share-worthy recipe was Sweet-Pickled Jalapeno and Onion and
Grasshopper Stir-Fry.
Before
you can fix this recipe, you need the ingredients and I’ve never seen
sweet-pickled jalapenos and onions in a grocery store. The first recipe is one that can be used for
lots of different purposes. It’s a
recipe to prepare one of the ingredients for the insect recipe.
Sweet-Pickled Jalapeno and Onion
Core
and seed a mess of jalapeno peppers (use rubber gloves, as the juices can soak
into your skin quite readily). Dehydrate
the cores and seeds for later grinding and powdering for other recipes. Cut the meats of the jalapenos and a big onion
(white onions are my favorite, as they tend to be stronger flavored) into one-inch
chunks. I like to generate about two
cups of each. The leftover will freeze
just fine if you want to pickle more.
Put the cut vegetables in jars that can be readily sealed (canning
jars).
Bring
to a boil, one cup water, 1 cup white vinegar, and three quarters of a cup of
sugar (more in those proportions as needed).
Pour the boiling brew quickly over the cut vegetables until they’re just
covered. Quickly seal the jars.
Set
the jars aside at least overnight, or a couple days to let the flavors blend
well.
Sweet-Pickled Jalapeno and Onion
and Grasshopper Stir-Fry
Heat
up a small amount of oil in a large frying pan.
When hot, put in about a cup of the drained sweet-pickled jalapenos and
onions. Stir nearly constantly until the
onions turn transluscent. Add about a
cup of grasshoppers and stir the mix until you’re certain the grasshoppers are
hot and re-cooked fully. If you start
with freshly killed hoppers, cook until they turn a deep reddish brown.
*****
There’s
more you can do with the pickle/stir-fry recipe. If you’ve got leftover peppers and onions,
they dehydrate into a nicely sweet and hot hard crunchy candy-like state. The leftover pickle juice can be re-boiled
and poured over boiled grasshoppers, pickling them the same way you did with the
peppers and onions. The hoppers are good
that way and they, too, can be dehydrated into a crispy candy.
Before
you crisp the hoppers, I need to tell you about the drumsticks. Properly eaten reveals them to be quite a
delicacy –at least it’s another favorite of mine. Take a drumstick and bite the tip off the
thick end. Gently bite down on the
narrow end and pull the thick end through your teeth and squeeze the meat out
as though it was a tiny tough sausage, or like a tiny tube of toothpaste from
which you’re extracting the last bits.
Grasshopper drumsticks are well worth the work, but it’s a bit
tedious. After you’ve tried the
drumsticks, then try dehydrating the rest into crispiness. I like to save the drumsticks before
candying. That brings us to candied
bugs. This has worked nicely on cicadas,
which can hatch out in vast numbers and can be very easily collected.
Candied Bugs
Make
a very-thick sweet syrup by stirring sugar into a liquid. I make mine with freshly squeezed fruit juice
like from raspberries or I use my sweet, hot fish and rice sauce. Pour the syrup over your pre-cooked bugs and
stir gently until they’re thoroughly coated.
They can even be previously dehydrated.
Dehydrate until the syrup is no longer drippy. It will still feel sticky when done. For convenience, I leave the bugs in the
dehydrator overnight. Spread the bugs
out on a non-absorbant flexible surface like foil or wax paper. Allow to cool –refrigerator or freezer really
speeds it up. When cool, the bugs should
flex off the sheets easily.
Other Basics
Fried: Use olive oil, as it’s not as bad for you as
other oils –however, be more patient, because it doesn’t do as well as other
oils at higher temperatures. Since
insects are quite delicate, stir very gently, but constantly.
Baked:
Low temps are recommended, as bugs will burn fairly quickly.
Dehydrated:
Like you would meat, since bugs really are meat. Very crispy, without burning or added oil
makes this a favorite method of mine. If
you don’t have a dehydrator, try your lowest oven setting for an hour, and then
checking for crispness from time to time –at least every 15 minutes, as your
lowest oven temp is probably quite a bit hotter than a dehydrator.
Pickled: Sweet pickled with juices from the first
recipe. Bring your juice to a boil and
pour over the bugs to cover. Serve when
cool. If you plan to store them, use a
glass canning jar and seal the lids very quickly after covering with the boiled
juice.
Crispy
Snacks: Use the recipe from any crisp rice cereal for crispy snacks,
substituting crisp bugs for a portion of the cereal. I usually go about half and half.
Chocolate-Covered: Melt chocolate in a double boiler. Stir crisp bugs into the chocolate. Remove the bugs and allow them to cool.
Spice-tossed: After frying, or baking with light oil, place
bugs in a plastic bag of your favorite seasoning and shake well. I like taco seasoning mix.
Broth
for Rice or Barley: After boiling the
bugs, use the broth/water for rice or barley.
Croutons: Put some crispy spiced and dehydrated beetles
on a salad.
Although some
people don’t consider non-insect invertebrates to be “bugs”, I’ll include some
of them here anyway. Many varieties of
slugs and snails are edible, as are earthworms. Put earthworms in peat or cornmeal for
a few days before you boil them (20 minutes, with garlic). It helps purge
the fine gritty dirt from their systems. They have a taste sort of like
earthy fish, with a texture similar to squid.
Sharing Your Creations
Public
presentations are fun, and a great way to spread the word about eating insects. When the people first arrive, they see the
display and gasp, “Ewww!”, “Oh gross!” “Are those real bugs?” Some turn away. Some slap their hands over their mouths. Some respond in more neutral ways or many
times, favorably. “Yeah. I had to eat bugs in survival school.” “Do you have any of those witchiti
grubs? I saw those on the Anthropology
Network or Cuisine Channel.” “I knew a
guy who ate a grasshopper.” “Do you
catch all these yourself?” “How do you
say that? EN-tomo-faggy?” “Oh wow! Are
those, like, the June bugs on our window screens?” “I’ve heard insects are edible. I’ve just never had an opportunity.” “Are these for us to eat?” “Can I try one?”
Don’t
work too hard to coax someone to try.
Allow the unwilling their right to refuse. Allow them their dignity and don’t ridicule
their choice not to try. Never sneak
bugs into someone’s food and giggle saying, “Ha ha ha! Guess what you just
ate!” Sometimes the reluctant will warm,
but often they’ll spit it back out or hack or even retch, making it harder to
get the mildly-bold to try. When you
force folks to try bugs, or surprise people “after” they’ve eaten them, you
give entomophagy, and yourself, a bad name.
Only encourage the willing to eat.
Obviously, they’ll be the most receptive. Those unwilling at first, often soften as
they watch willing eaters.
To help popularize entomophagy, I
really believe we’ve got to avoid making it a political issue. Avoid suggestion
of any legislation (green or humanitarian). If anyone feels a threat, they’ll
fight it. Present entomophagy as simply a fun new food and not politics. Insects and other little invertebrates are
just other kinds of animals. They’re no dirtier, and often cleaner than those
animals we accept as food. Present edibility to Scout groups, 4-H, other youth
events like Fear Factor events. University and high school/middle school groups
like home economics, anthropology, biology, nutritional studies are good
audiences to target, as are state Departments of Conservation and Natural
Resources.
Brainstorm those publicity ideas! Find a way to attach bugs to a historical
organization like I did. My Johnson County Historical Society hosted its first
foraged feast, featuring many wild insects, in memory of the 1875 grasshopper
plague and subsequent feast.
There’s lots of data to refute the claims that eating insects will save our environment and the world from hunger. Of course, there’s data to say otherwise. Although entomophagy could maybe help in those areas, I think our main aim should be the fun and unique taste treats which would otherwise be missed without intentionally eating bugs. I didn’t mention anything potentially political and my historical society was in unanimous agreement that we’d do the bug feast.
Dispel the cultural fears and play up the nutritional and recreational gains (it was fun one night after a church function to have little kids and even white-haired elders catching June bugs under the porch light for one of my up-coming programs). Possible environmental and humanitarian benefits could be reserved for audiences where you know that interest would be positively tapped. Most people will resist the thought of infringing on their beef, pork and poultry. I, for one, am against anything that would drive their prices up. We must figure out how to get insect prices down to compete with mainstream meats. If they’re as easy to raise, and take as few resources as is claimed, it shouldn’t be too difficult.
There’s lots of data to refute the claims that eating insects will save our environment and the world from hunger. Of course, there’s data to say otherwise. Although entomophagy could maybe help in those areas, I think our main aim should be the fun and unique taste treats which would otherwise be missed without intentionally eating bugs. I didn’t mention anything potentially political and my historical society was in unanimous agreement that we’d do the bug feast.
Dispel the cultural fears and play up the nutritional and recreational gains (it was fun one night after a church function to have little kids and even white-haired elders catching June bugs under the porch light for one of my up-coming programs). Possible environmental and humanitarian benefits could be reserved for audiences where you know that interest would be positively tapped. Most people will resist the thought of infringing on their beef, pork and poultry. I, for one, am against anything that would drive their prices up. We must figure out how to get insect prices down to compete with mainstream meats. If they’re as easy to raise, and take as few resources as is claimed, it shouldn’t be too difficult.
Bibliography
Angier,
Bradford. How to Stay Alive in the Woods. Macmillan Publishing Co. New York. 1956.
DeFoliart,
Gene, Florence Vaccarello Dunkel, David Gracer, Ed. Food Insects Newsletter:
Chronicle of a Changing Culture. Aardvark Global Publishing. Salt Lake
City. 2009.
Gordon,
David George. The Eat-A-Bug Cookbook. Ten Speed Press. Berkeley, CA. 1998.
Gordon,
David George. The Secret World of Slugs and Snails: Life in the Very Slow
Lane. Sasquatch Books. Seattle. 2010.
Herter,
George Leonard and Berthe E. How to Get Out of the Rat Race and Live on $10
a Month. Herter's, Inc. Waseca, MN. 1975.
Holt,
Vincent M. Why Not Eat Insects? Pryor Publications Whitstable and
Walsall. Whitstable, Kent, UK. 2007
reprint of 1885 publication.
Jaden,
Jenna, and the University of Maryland Cicadamaniacs. Cicada-Licious (2nd
ed.) University of Maryland. 2004.
MacClancy,
Jeremy and Jeya Henry, Helen Macbeth ed's. Consuming the Inedible:
Neglected Dimensions of Food Choice. Berghahn Books. NY. 2009.
Manes,
Stephen. Chocolate-Covered Ants. Scholastic, Inc. NY. 1990
Menzel,
Peter, and Faith D'Aluisio. Man Eating Bugs: The Art and Science of Eating
Insects. Ten Speed Press. Berkeley, CA. 1998.
Naylor,
Phyllis Reynolds. Beetles, Lightly
Toasted. Bantam Doubleday Dell Books for Young Readers. NY. (1987) 1989.
Ramos-Eldorduy,
Julieta. Creepy Crawly Cuisine: The Gourmet Guide to Edible Insects. Park Street Press, Rochester, VT. 1998.
Rockwell,
Thomas. How to Eat Fried Worms.
Yearling. NY. (1973) 2006
Rost,
Amy, compiler. Survival Wisdom and
Know-How: Everything You Need to Know to Subsist in the Wilderness. Black
Dog and Leventhal Publishers, Inc. NY. 2007.
Taylor,
Ronald L. and Barbara J. Carter. Entertaining With Insects. Salutek
Publishing Co. Yorba Linda, CA. 1996.
U.S.
Army, Marine Corps, Navy, Air Force. Survival, Evasion and Recovery.
1999.
Wild
Edible Plants
Angier,
Bradford. Feasting Free on Wild Edibles.
Stackpole Books. Harrisburg, PA. 1983
Angier,
Bradford. Field Guide to Edible Wild
Plants. Stackpole Books. Harrisburg,
PA. 1982.
Brill,
Steve and Evelyn Dean. Identifying and Harvesting Edible and
Medicinal Plants: in Wild (and Not So Wild) Places. HarperCollins Publishers. NY. 1994.
The Complete Guide
to Edible Wild Plants. Department of the Army. Skyhorse Publishing. NY. 2009.
Couplan,
Francois, PhD. The Encyclopedia of Edible
Plants of North America. Keats Publishing, Inc. New Canaan, CT. 1998.
Forey,
Pamela, and Cecelia Fitzsimmons. An
Instant Guide to Edible Plants.
Gramercy Books. NY. 2001.
Phillips,
Jan. Wild
Edibles of Missouri. Missouri
Department of Conservation. Jefferson City, MO.
1979.
Tatum,
Billy Joe. Wild Foods Field Guide and
Cookbook. Workman Publishing Co. NY.
1976.
Plant
and Insect Identification
Arnett,
Ross H, Jr and Richard L Jacques, Jr. Simon
and Schuster’s Guide to Insects.
Simon and Schuster, NY. 1981.
Brockman,
C. Frank. A Field Guide to the Major Native and Introduced Species North of
Mexico: Trees of North America. Golden Press. NY. 1979.
Borror,
Donald J. and Richard E. White. A Field Guide to Insects: America north of
Mexico. Peterson Field Guides. Houghton Mifflin Company. Boston. 1970
Capinera,
John L., et al. Field Guide to
Grasshoppers, Katydids and Crickets of the United States. Comstock Publishing Associates, Cornell
University Press. Ithaca, NY. 2004.
Cranshaw,
Whitney. Garden Insects of North America. Princeton University Press.
Princeton, NJ. 2004.
Denison,
Edgar. Missouri Wildflowers.
Missouri Department of Conservation.
Jefferson City, MO. 1978
Heitzman,
J. Richard and Joan E. Butterflies and
Moths of Missouri. Missouri
Department of Conservation. Jefferson City, MO, 1987.
Niering,
William A. and Nancy C. Olmstead. The
Audubon Society Field Guide to North American Wildflowers. Alfred A. Knopf.
NY. 1979
Settergren,
Carl and R.E.McDermott. Trees of Missouri. University of
Missouri Agricultural Experiment Station.
1966.
Venning,
Frank D. A Guide to Field Identification: Wildflowers of North America. Golden Press.
NY. 1984.
White,
Richard E. A Field Guide to the Beetles of North America. Peterson Field Guides, Houghton Mifflin
Company. Boston. 1983.
Zim, Herbert S. and Clarence Cottam. Insects. Golden Press. NY. 1956.
Websites
June
bugs and More http://intotheborderlands.blogspot.com/2008/06/eating-brown.html
Food
Insects Newsletter
http://www.hollowtop.com/finl_html/finl.html
http://www.food-insects.com/
Grasshopper
Recipes
http://www.faculty.de.gcsu.edu/~cbader/ghprecwithinsects.html
How
Stuff Works "How Entomophagy Works"
http://people.howstuffworks.com/entomophagy4.htm
Girl
Meets Bug "Eat Bugs, Save the World"
http://www.girlmeetsbug.com/
Facebook
“groups”: "Missouri
Entomophagy" and "Wild Edibles of Missouri" are fun and active.
2 comments:
If you don't know if a bug's edible or not, first try to look it up through some of the references listed. There used to be an international known-edible insects list, but I can't find it on-line now. I'm glad I printed one. Anyway, I check that list for the species in question. If I don't find it, I consider its family. If the family is extensively listed, it doesn't seem to have obvious defenses and if its environment/food plants are safe, I'll consider it for eating --but like the universal edibility test stresses, tiny bits at a time. I'll ask around, too! That's one wonderful thing about the Internet!
Here's an example of an exception to the rule "Red orange yellow, avoid that fellow. Green black or brown, wolf it down". Here's a green and brown caterpillar whose sting in a mouth or throat can cause swelling to the point of suffocation: http://www.whatsthatbug.com/2009/08/31/saddleback-caterpillar-9/
Post a Comment